Is the background of the article properly identified?; do the article’s major claims make sense,and are they well supported with evidence and argument?

Problem (1 page)

In this final section of the exercise, I want you to identify one problem with the article, that is, some aspect of the research that you find questionable in some way.

Consider questions such as: does the article address a truly important question?; is the background of the article properly identified?; do the article’s major claims make sense, and are they well supported with evidence and argument?; do the article’s conclusions follow logically from its major claims and arguments.