What do you think of the argument? What do you find compelling or problematic and why? Has the author committed any logical fallacies?
Environmental Politics
Write a paragraph that stands back and considers how the author has constructed their argument. Assess it as a piece of writing. What devices have they used, what is the structure, how have they supported their argument ? Treat this is a kind of dissection of the blog using what you have learned from reading Weston’s Rule book for Arguments.
iii. Critical response / counter argument
In the third part, present your own response to the argument you have just summarised. This is where your own critical assessment comes in. What do you think of the argument? What do you find compelling or problematic and why? Has the author committed any logical fallacies? Remember that critique is not always negative – you might well agree with what the author has argued.
Your response might take the form of a disagreement with part or all of the argument, a further elaboration of it, or a question or problem arising from it that you think merits further discussion. You need to explain your response to the argument persuasively. Give reasons and evidence to support it.